As you may have heard, Tesla have signaled that they will attempt to sue Top Gear for defamation for their road test of the Tesla Roadster all the way back in 2008. Over the last few days Tesla have gone on the offensive and used almost every media outlet available to get their side of the story out into the public – something which Andy Wilman, the producer of Top Gear, felt he had to respond to.
What baffles me the most is I thought Top Gear’s review was actually rather fair – they explained the good and bad points of the car and based their own conclusion on that information. There have been other cars which have received far worse treatment (arguably because they deserved it) such as the Vauxhall Vectra – which Jeremy famously described as being “designed in a coffee break by people who couldn’t care less about cars”. But did we ever see a lawsuit from Vauxhall? No.
Below is Andy’s article from topgear.com
You may know that Tesla has issued a writ against Top Gear for defamation and malicious falsehood over the road test that we broadcast of the Tesla Roadster in December 2008. The normal procedure for the BBC in a legal case is to acknowledge receipt of the other party’s claim, and then say no more and get on with preparing its defence for court.
Tesla, however, doesn’t seem content to wait for the legal eagles to settle matters. On the contrary, it’s been very busy promoting its side of the argument through the media. Why even last night the Top Gear office accidentally received an email sent from a Public Relations firm to The One Show, asking if it would like to have the Tesla spokesperson on their programme to talk about the case. It says: “PHA Media represent Tesla and this could make for a fantastic interview.” And the PHA man’s not finished there. “The presenters could have some fun with this.” He adds. “Matt and Alex could even take the Tesla for a spin and test it out, reaffirming its virtues?” Plenty of respect for editorial independence in that last line there and I wish the chaps from PHA Media all the best in their crusade.
Read more